The End of the Influencer? Most Consumers Doubt Social Media Influencers Use the Products They Promote

Survey: Only 11% of Americans Believe Influencers Deliver Trustworthy Reviews, While a Majority of Americans (53%) Rely Most on Recommendations From Product Experts

‍

CHICAGO, Sept 7, 2022 /PRNewswire/ -- The Decline of Trust in Social Media Influencers

The era of influencer marketing is facing a seismic shift. Once a dominant force on social media platforms, social media influencers are rapidly losing their credibility. According to a survey of 1,000 U.S. adults commissioned by The Desire Company, only 11% of Americans believe that influencers deliver trustworthy reviews. A growing number of consumers are waking up to the reality that influencer promotions often prioritize personal branding over product authenticity.

A Growing Disconnect Between Influencers and Consumers

This shift in consumer behavior is fueled by the disconnect between influencers and the average person. A staggering 87% of respondents said it’s likely that influencers don’t even use the products they promote. Social media has given influencers the power to promote products to millions of followers, but that clout no longer guarantees trust or effectiveness.

When the Hype Doesn’t Match the Product

More than 4 in 5 (82%) consumers who made purchases based on influencer recommendations reported having a negative experience. The most common complaint? The product didn’t match the influencer’s claims. This decline in authenticity is leading many consumers to question the value of influencer marketing altogether.

The Impact on Brand Loyalty and Sales

Poor experiences have consequences. Over 42% of those who had a negative encounter with an influencer-promoted product said they were unlikely to buy from that brand again. Businesses that once relied heavily on influencer marketing are now reassessing their strategies. While influencers may drive short-term sales, the long-term impact on consumer trust and brand loyalty is critical.

The Rise of Expert-Led Content

Amid the decline of influencers, expert-driven content is gaining momentum. A majority (53%) of Americans now say they rely most on product experts when making purchasing decisions. These experts, who often create long form content, deliver deep insights that resonate with consumers looking for substance over flash.

Why Expert Content Feels More Authentic

Unlike influencers, product experts don’t rely on hype or paid promotions. Their reviews are rooted in real-world experience, often tied to a specific profession or deep knowledge base. This shift reflects broader trends in consumer attitudes—people want relevance, quality, and expertise, not just sponsored posts.

The Problem With Personal Branding in Influencing

Social media influencers build entire businesses on personal branding. But personal branding can be a double-edged sword. When a platform or persona overtakes product integrity, consumers begin to feel manipulated rather than informed. Micro influencers and smaller influencers may offer better engagement, but the issue of authenticity remains.

From Platforms to People: Changing Purchasing Decisions

Social media platforms like Instagram and Facebook have long been the battleground for influencer marketing. But as users grow more skeptical, even these platforms are losing their persuasive power. More consumers are turning to trusted communities, expert reviews, and podcasts for guidance on purchasing decisions.

Consumers Demand More Value and Less Hype

Consumers today are savvier than ever. They’re not just following trends—they’re analyzing them. They want value, usefulness, and accuracy. They want to know that a product will perform in real life, not just look good in videos. And they’re willing to pay for that kind of assurance.

The Shift Toward Sustainable Engagement

Influencer marketing, in its current form, is struggling to maintain sustainability. Consumers are burned out from misleading ads, clickbait promotions, and empty recommendations. They’re seeking real connections, trustworthy reviews, and honest information that helps them make smart purchasing decisions.

Businesses Are Reimagining Their Marketing Strategy

The future of marketing lies not in mass followers but in meaningful engagement. As brands evaluate the effectiveness of influencer campaigns, many are choosing to collaborate with experts who can offer more than just reach—they offer relevance, accuracy, and authority. This strategy reflects a broader shift toward creating real value.

Social Media’s Role in the Future of Reviews

Social media is still a powerful tool—but how it’s used matters. Instead of relying on influencers to carry their message, brands are integrating expert-led content, articles, and how-to videos into their media strategy. They’re focusing on building long-term relationships with consumers through authenticity, not hype.

The Role of SEO and Long-Form Content

As the digital landscape evolves, SEO and long form content are becoming key tools in winning over skeptical consumers. Detailed product reviews, educational content, and expert insights are more likely to appear in organic search results—and more likely to be trusted by users.

Tools That Help Create Trust

Brands are investing in tools and platforms that support expert-driven storytelling. The effort to maintain consumer trust takes time, but it pays off in engagement, sales, and loyalty. Whether through podcasts, articles, or videos, businesses are using expert voices to rise above the noise.

Influencer Marketing Isn’t Dead But It’s Being Replaced

The influencer era may not be entirely over, but it’s certainly being redefined. The shift from influencers to experts doesn’t mean an end to personal branding or promotions—it means a focus on quality, sustainability, and true audience connection. The most successful businesses are the ones adapting their strategy to align with what consumers actually value.

Conclusion: The New Reality of Digital Influence

We’ve reached a critical moment. The rise of influencers once led to a gold rush of content, partnerships, and ads. But the growing number of disillusioned consumers is changing the game. Authenticity, credibility, and expert knowledge are now driving purchasing decisions.

Brands that understand this shift and respond with thoughtful, expert-led content will build the strongest connections, the most loyal communities, and the most sustainable sales growth.

The end of influencers isn’t the end of influencing. It’s the beginning of a new era rooted in value, expertise, and trust.

About The Desire Company

The Desire Company is the world's only community of Experts who tell the truth about the products they actually use and trust. Our mission is to empower shoppers to make more educated, confident purchase decisions by providing reliable, expert-driven product reviews, how-tos, and classes. The company was created around the passions of accomplished professionals at the top of their game, in order to democratize their knowledge and build a community to share it.

LATEST PRESS

NEW TO THE DESIRE COMPANY BLOG? START HERE!

READ OUR MOST POPULAR BLOGS